CSS Solved Essay · CSS 2023 essay solved · English Essay paper · Q2

The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning.

By Shan Ul Rehman, Founder and Editor · Prepared with AI research assistance, then checked and edited by the author ·

Cover of the CSS 2023 solved essay, question 2: The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning.

The CSS 2023 essay solved for question 2: a thesis statement, a 9-part outline, 5 arguments with sources, 3 counterarguments answered and 5 mistakes to avoid on this topic.

What the examiner is asking. Examine why people or authorities may resort to force when they cannot persuade others through reason. Assess the relationship between coercion, legitimacy, dialogue and power, while recognising that lawful force may sometimes be necessary to protect people and enforce legitimate rules.

Write your outline — get it checked

What this page is. A plan to build your own essay from, not a full essay to copy and not an official FPSC answer. How the CSS 2023 analyses were checked.

Thesis statement

The habitual use of force often signals a failure of confidence in reason, because coercion can silence opposition but cannot by itself secure consent or legitimacy; nevertheless, proportionate lawful force may be necessary to prevent immediate harm, making reasoned justification and accountability the true tests of authority.

The central debate

Does reliance on force reveal an inability or unwillingness to justify power rationally? The strongest interpretation is that coercion often substitutes for legitimacy and persuasion, but the proverb becomes too absolute if it treats every lawful or protective use of force as fear of reason.

Scope of the essay. Apply the proposition to family and social disputes, political authority, protest, policing, international relations and conflict resolution. Distinguish arbitrary violence from proportionate lawful enforcement, and persuasion from manipulation or propaganda.

Read the topic carefully. Do not equate every use of force with cowardice or irrationality. The topic is strongest when analysed as a critique of force used in place of argument, consent and lawful authority.

Key terms

Force
The use or threat of physical, legal, institutional or material power to compel behaviour.
Reasoning
The process of giving and assessing evidence, arguments and explanations to reach a defensible judgement.
Coercion
Compelling someone to act through threats, penalties or the removal of meaningful choice.
Legitimacy
The recognised right of an authority or institution to exercise power, grounded in lawful procedure, consent and public justification.
Persuasion
Seeking agreement through reasons, evidence and communication rather than compulsion.

Essay outline

  1. I.

    Introduction: force can compel obedience, but it cannot establish the truth of an argument.

    Introduce the contrast between coercion and persuasion and define the limits of the proverb.

  2. II.

    People resort to force when they lack persuasive arguments or fear scrutiny.

    Explain how intimidation avoids evidence, debate and accountability by making disagreement costly.

  3. III.

    Political authority built on coercion suffers from a deficit of legitimacy and public trust.

    Use Hannah Arendt's distinction between power sustained by collective consent and violence used instrumentally.

  4. IV.

    Force suppresses dissent temporarily while leaving the underlying grievances unresolved.

    Show how censorship, repression and intimidation can drive opposition underground and intensify resentment.

  5. V.

    Reasoned dialogue produces more durable solutions by enabling compromise and shared ownership.

    Discuss negotiation, parliamentary debate, mediation and constitutional processes as methods of managing disagreement.

  6. VI.

    Nonviolent resistance can challenge coercive systems by mobilising broad participation and legitimacy.

    Use comparative civil-resistance research to explain how mass participation and loyalty shifts can make nonviolent campaigns effective.

  7. VII.

    Lawful and proportionate force remains necessary to protect people from immediate violence.

    Distinguish legitimate policing and defence from arbitrary repression, collective punishment and political intimidation.

  8. VIII.

    Accountable institutions must make every coercive act necessary, proportionate and reviewable.

    Discuss due process, independent courts, oversight, transparent rules and remedies against abuse.

  9. IX.

    Conclusion: reason should govern authority, while limited force remains answerable to law.

    Conclude that force is no substitute for legitimacy, persuasion or justice, even where lawful protection is unavoidable.

Arguments for the essay

Prepare 12 to 18 arguments. 5 here for reference, each stated, reasoned and sourced; the study guide below shows ways to grow them on this topic.

  • Coercion often indicates that an authority cannot obtain consent through credible reasons.

    When citizens or interlocutors cannot challenge a decision without punishment, compliance reflects fear rather than agreement; the authority's legitimacy is therefore weakened. [1]

  • Violence may silence opposition without resolving the causes of conflict.

    Coercive action suppresses visible resistance but leaves grievances, exclusion and distrust intact, creating conditions for renewed confrontation. [1] [2]

  • Nonviolent campaigns can outperform armed campaigns because they attract broader participation and legitimacy.

    The comparative dataset discussed by Chenoweth and Stephan identifies mobilisation, external support and loyalty shifts as mechanisms that can make nonviolent resistance strategically effective. [2]

  • Reasoned public deliberation strengthens institutions by allowing citizens to contest and improve decisions.

    Arendt's account links political power to people acting together and sustaining consent through public discussion, not merely to the state's coercive capacity. [1]

  • The proverb must allow for lawful protective force where dialogue cannot stop immediate harm.

    Police intervention, self-defence and enforcement of court orders may protect rights, but must satisfy legality, necessity, proportionality and accountability. [1]

Evidence and examples

  • Coercion often indicates that an authority cannot obtain consent through credible reasons. [1]

    How to use it: When citizens or interlocutors cannot challenge a decision without punishment, compliance reflects fear rather than agreement; the authority's legitimacy is therefore weakened.

  • Violence may silence opposition without resolving the causes of conflict. [1] [2]

    How to use it: Coercive action suppresses visible resistance but leaves grievances, exclusion and distrust intact, creating conditions for renewed confrontation.

  • Nonviolent campaigns can outperform armed campaigns because they attract broader participation and legitimacy. [2]

    How to use it: The comparative dataset discussed by Chenoweth and Stephan identifies mobilisation, external support and loyalty shifts as mechanisms that can make nonviolent resistance strategically effective.

  • Reasoned public deliberation strengthens institutions by allowing citizens to contest and improve decisions. [1]

    How to use it: Arendt's account links political power to people acting together and sustaining consent through public discussion, not merely to the state's coercive capacity.

  • The proverb must allow for lawful protective force where dialogue cannot stop immediate harm. [1]

    How to use it: Police intervention, self-defence and enforcement of court orders may protect rights, but must satisfy legality, necessity, proportionality and accountability.

Counterarguments and rebuttals

  • Objection: Force is sometimes the only way to stop an aggressor or protect vulnerable people.

    Answer: Correct: the proposition should not be read as absolute pacifism. It condemns force as a substitute for reasoning, not proportionate force used under law to prevent imminent harm.

  • Objection: Some actors use peaceful language strategically while refusing genuine compromise.

    Answer: Reasoning is not mere rhetoric. It requires factual honesty, reciprocal listening and willingness to be corrected; propaganda and bad-faith negotiation are not genuine alternatives to force.

  • Objection: Nonviolent movements do not always succeed, and some violent campaigns have achieved objectives.

    Answer: The research identifies comparative tendencies rather than universal laws. The argument is that nonviolent mobilisation often creates stronger legitimacy and participation, not that it guarantees success.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Do not describe every police action or defensive use of force as irrational.
  • Do not present Hannah Arendt's distinctions as a claim that violence never has instrumental effects.
  • Do not confuse persuasion with propaganda or emotional manipulation.
  • Do not assume nonviolent resistance guarantees victory.
  • Do not ignore legal standards such as necessity, proportionality and accountability.

Related CSS essay topics

  • 2020 Q4: Polarized politics and the challenges of democracy in Pakistan.
  • 2022 Q2: Digital democracy, social media and political participation.
  • 2024 Q10: Political Polarization; Governance and Society.

How to write this essay: a study guide

A plan for writing “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning” yourself, built from the analysis above. The method that applies to every topic is in how to write any CSS essay.

Reading the question

“The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning” is a claim to test, not a subject to describe. This page takes a position on it: The habitual use of force often signals a failure of confidence in reason, because coercion can silence opposition but cannot by itself secure consent or legitimacy; nevertheless, proportionate lawful force may be necessary to prevent immediate harm, making reasoned justification and accountability the true tests of authority.

Terms to pin down in your own words before you argue from them: Force, Reasoning, Coercion, Legitimacy and Persuasion.

The introduction, in four sentences

  1. Setting. Apply the proposition to family and social disputes, political authority, protest, policing, international relations and conflict resolution.
  2. Definition. Force and Reasoning.
  3. The debate. Does reliance on force reveal an inability or unwillingness to justify power rationally?
  4. Your thesis, rewritten from “The habitual use of force often signals a failure of confidence in reason, because coercion can silence opposition but cannot by itself secure consent or legitimacy; nevertheless, proportionate lawful force may be necessary to prevent immediate harm, making reasoned justification and accountability the true tests of authority.”

Word budget for these 9 sections

  1. I. Introduction: force can compel obedience, but it cannot establish the truth of an argument. — about 250–300 words.
  2. II. People resort to force when they lack persuasive arguments or fear scrutiny. — about 290–350 words.
  3. III. Political authority built on coercion suffers from a deficit of legitimacy and public trust. — about 290–350 words.
  4. IV. Force suppresses dissent temporarily while leaving the underlying grievances unresolved. — about 290–350 words.
  5. V. Reasoned dialogue produces more durable solutions by enabling compromise and shared ownership. — about 290–350 words.
  6. VI. Nonviolent resistance can challenge coercive systems by mobilising broad participation and legitimacy. — about 290–350 words.
  7. VII. Lawful and proportionate force remains necessary to protect people from immediate violence. — about 290–350 words.
  8. VIII. Accountable institutions must make every coercive act necessary, proportionate and reviewable. — about 290–350 words.
  9. IX. Conclusion: reason should govern authority, while limited force remains answerable to law. — about 200–240 words.

From 5 arguments to 12–18

  • Argue against “Coercion often indicates that an authority cannot obtain consent through credible reasons”, then answer your own objection.
  • Restate “Violence may silence opposition without resolving the causes of conflict” for a different level: the individual, an institution, the state or the international system.
  • Trace “Force” through time: what it meant a generation ago, what it means now, and where it is heading.
  • Ground “Nonviolent campaigns can outperform armed campaigns because they attract broader participation and legitimacy” in Pakistan with a dated fact or a named institution.
  • Ask what political philosophy, governance, conflict resolution, democracy and human rights would each say about this topic, and write one argument from each that the list above does not cover.

Counterarguments to prepare

The objection to meet first: “Force is sometimes the only way to stop an aggressor or protect vulnerable people.” Then “Some actors use peaceful language strategically while refusing genuine compromise.” Write your own answer to each before reading the one above.

Evidence for this topic

2 sources cited on this page, starting with Hannah Arendt (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy).

Questions about this essay

What is the thesis statement for “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning”?
The habitual use of force often signals a failure of confidence in reason, because coercion can silence opposition but cannot by itself secure consent or legitimacy; nevertheless, proportionate lawful force may be necessary to prevent immediate harm, making reasoned justification and accountability the true tests of authority.
Which paper was “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning” set in?
Question 2 of the CSS 2023 English Essay paper.
What is the central debate in “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning”?
Does reliance on force reveal an inability or unwillingness to justify power rationally? The strongest interpretation is that coercion often substitutes for legitimacy and persuasion, but the proverb becomes too absolute if it treats every lawful or protective use of force as fear of reason.
Which terms should I define in an essay on “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning”?
Force: The use or threat of physical, legal, institutional or material power to compel behaviour. Reasoning: The process of giving and assessing evidence, arguments and explanations to reach a defensible judgement. Coercion: Compelling someone to act through threats, penalties or the removal of meaningful choice. Legitimacy: The recognised right of an authority or institution to exercise power, grounded in lawful procedure, consent and public justification.
What is the strongest objection to the thesis on “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning”?
Force is sometimes the only way to stop an aggressor or protect vulnerable people. Answer: Correct: the proposition should not be read as absolute pacifism. It condemns force as a substitute for reasoning, not proportionate force used under law to prevent imminent harm.
What mistakes should I avoid on “The one who uses force is afraid of reasoning”?
Do not describe every police action or defensive use of force as irrational. Do not present Hannah Arendt's distinctions as a claim that violence never has instrumental effects. Do not confuse persuasion with propaganda or emotional manipulation.

Sources

  1. [1] Hannah Arendt — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Entry accessed 2026-11-07
  2. [2] Why Civil Resistance Works: The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent Conflict — International Security / Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Summer 2008

More CSS solved essays

The rest of the CSS 2023 paper · All CSS solved essays · Every CSS essay topic, 2016–2026 · CSS essay past papers