Passage 23 of 30

Convenience and Human Dependence

261 words · aim for about 87 (roughly 78–96)

Original practice passage. Written for practice at CSS standard, with AI assistance — it is not a passage from an FPSC past paper. For the real papers, see Précis & Composition past papers.

1A tool is valuable because it extends human ability, but a tool can become a source of dependence when its user loses the skill that once made the tool useful. 2Navigation applications help drivers find unfamiliar routes, yet constant reliance on them may weaken their sense of direction. 3Calculators save time, but they cannot replace an understanding of quantities. 4Digital communication connects distant people, though it may also reduce the practice of attentive conversation. 5The issue is not whether technology is good or bad. 6It is whether people remain capable of choosing when to use it and when to act without it. 7Schools should teach both digital competence and the underlying skills that technology supports. 8Families can also protect periods of undistracted conversation. 9A healthy relationship with tools preserves human judgment; an unhealthy one allows convenience to decide what people notice, remember and value. 10The distinction between using a tool and surrendering judgment becomes more important as automated systems enter work and education. 11Software can sort information quickly, but users must still question the quality of its inputs and the fairness of its outputs. 12A recommendation is not a command, and a calculated score is not a complete description of a person. 13Schools and workplaces should preserve opportunities to practise independent reasoning, manual competence and face-to-face cooperation. 14These abilities provide alternatives when systems fail and help people notice when automation produces an unreasonable result. 15Convenience is valuable when it gives human beings more time for meaningful work; it is costly when it removes the skills needed to supervise the convenience itself.

Task. Write a précis of approximately one-third length and give it a suitable title.

This passage in figures

Words
261
Sentences
15
Average sentence
17 words
Longest sentence
30 words
Your précis
78–96 words, 3–5 sentences
Sentences per précis sentence
about 4

It opens: “A tool is valuable because it extends human ability, but a tool can become a source of dependence when its user loses the skill that once made the tool useful.”

It closes: “Convenience is valuable when it gives human beings more time for meaningful work; it is costly when it removes the skills needed to supervise the convenience itself.”

How to use these figures, the method step by step, and the mistakes that cost marks: the précis guide.

Model précis

Write your own first, then compare.

Show the model précis for this passage

Central idea

Tools extend human ability but create dependence when the skills behind them are lost; what matters is keeping the capacity to choose when to use them and to supervise automated systems, so that convenience serves judgment instead of replacing it.

Use Tools Without Surrendering Judgment

Tools extend ability but breed dependence when users lose the skills behind them. What matters is whether people can still choose when to do without them. Schools and families should therefore keep those skills and undistracted conversation alive, so tools serve judgment rather than dictate attention. With automation, users must question inputs and fairness, for a recommendation is no command. Independent reasoning and practical skills provide fallbacks and expose unreasonable outputs. Convenience is good when it frees time for meaningful work, bad when it erodes the skills needed to oversee it.

91 words, title not counted, against a target of 87.

Where each sentence comes from

  1. Tools extend ability but breed dependence when users lose the skills behind them. From passage sentence 1
  2. What matters is whether people can still choose when to do without them. From passage sentences 5, 6
  3. Schools and families should therefore keep those skills and undistracted conversation alive, so tools serve judgment rather than dictate attention. From passage sentences 7, 8, 9
  4. With automation, users must question inputs and fairness, for a recommendation is no command. From passage sentences 10, 11, 12
  5. Independent reasoning and practical skills provide fallbacks and expose unreasonable outputs. From passage sentences 13, 14
  6. Convenience is good when it frees time for meaningful work, bad when it erodes the skills needed to oversee it. From passage sentence 15

Left out: sentence 2 (example: navigation apps and the sense of direction); sentence 3 (example: calculators and the understanding of quantities); sentence 4 (example: digital messaging and attentive conversation).

Why this title

  • Use Tools Without Surrendering Judgment names the subject and what the passage argues about it.
  • Technology Is Harmful is weaker. Sentence 5: the issue is not whether technology is good or bad.
  • The Wonders of Science is weaker. Praises the tools and ignores the dependence the passage warns of.

Mistakes this passage invites

  • Turning the passage against technology. Sentence 5 refuses to ask whether technology is good or bad.
  • Keeping the navigation app, the calculator and the messaging of sentences 2 to 4, which are examples.
  • Copying the closing antithesis of sentence 15 word for word.

Model précis written with AI assistance to this site’s précis rules, then read and approved by Shan Ul Rehman. It is one good answer, not the only one, and not an FPSC answer.

To have your précis marked out of 20, open the Answer Checker, choose Précis & Composition, paste this passage as the Original Passage, then add your précis with its title on the first line.

Check my précis