Passage 19 of 30

Markets Need Rules to Remain Open

268 words · aim for about 89 (roughly 80–98)

Original practice passage. Written for practice at CSS standard, with AI assistance — it is not a passage from an FPSC past paper. For the real papers, see Précis & Composition past papers.

1Markets are most productive when people can enter them, compete and trust that agreements will be honoured. 2Competition encourages firms to improve quality and reduce costs, while trade allows consumers to access goods that cannot be produced efficiently at home. 3Yet markets do not regulate every consequence of economic activity. 4A factory may pollute a river because the cost is transferred to nearby residents; a dominant firm may prevent new competitors from entering; employers may shift risks onto workers who have little bargaining power. 5Rules are therefore not the enemy of markets. 6Properly designed regulation protects the conditions under which fair competition can take place. 7It must be transparent, consistent and proportionate, otherwise compliance becomes a privilege available only to large firms. 8Economic freedom is meaningful when it is accompanied by responsibility. 9The purpose of market institutions is not to eliminate profit, but to prevent private advantage from being built on public harm. 10Regulation is credible only when the regulator is independent, competent and accountable. 11Rules that are announced but not enforced create advantages for firms willing to ignore them. 12Excessive or unpredictable regulation, however, can discourage new businesses and place a heavier burden on small enterprises than on large corporations. 13Policymakers should consult affected groups, publish the reasons for decisions and review whether a rule is achieving its purpose. 14Competition authorities must be able to investigate concentration of market power without political interference. 15Consumers need practical remedies when products are unsafe or contracts are deceptive. 16The objective is a market in which success comes from better service and innovation rather than from the ability to avoid responsibility.

Task. Write a précis of approximately one-third length and give it a suitable title.

This passage in figures

Words
268
Sentences
16
Average sentence
17 words
Longest sentence
34 words
Your précis
80–98 words, 4–5 sentences
Sentences per précis sentence
about 4

It opens: “Markets are most productive when people can enter them, compete and trust that agreements will be honoured.”

It closes: “The objective is a market in which success comes from better service and innovation rather than from the ability to avoid responsibility.”

How to use these figures, the method step by step, and the mistakes that cost marks: the précis guide.

Model précis

Write your own first, then compare.

Show the model précis for this passage

Central idea

Markets thrive on open entry and trust but do not correct their own harms, so transparent, proportionate and enforced regulation by an independent regulator protects fair competition, and profit then comes from serving people better rather than from shifting harm onto the public.

Fair Rules Keep Markets Open and Honest

Markets thrive on open entry, competition and honoured contracts, and trade widens choice. Yet they leave harms unchecked: pollution borne by neighbours, monopolies blocking rivals and risks pushed onto weak workers. Regulation thus protects fair competition, provided it is transparent, consistent and proportionate rather than a burden only large firms can bear. Regulators must be independent and competent, enforce rules, explain decisions, review outcomes and curb market power, while consumers need remedies. Freedom entails responsibility: profit is legitimate when earned through better service and innovation, not by shifting harm onto the public.

92 words, title not counted, against a target of 89.

Where each sentence comes from

  1. Markets thrive on open entry, competition and honoured contracts, and trade widens choice. From passage sentences 1, 2
  2. Yet they leave harms unchecked: pollution borne by neighbours, monopolies blocking rivals and risks pushed onto weak workers. From passage sentences 3, 4
  3. Regulation thus protects fair competition, provided it is transparent, consistent and proportionate rather than a burden only large firms can bear. From passage sentences 5, 6, 7, 12
  4. Regulators must be independent and competent, enforce rules, explain decisions, review outcomes and curb market power, while consumers need remedies. From passage sentences 10, 11, 13, 14, 15
  5. Freedom entails responsibility: profit is legitimate when earned through better service and innovation, not by shifting harm onto the public. From passage sentences 8, 9, 16

Every sentence of the passage is folded into the précis; none is left out.

Why this title

  • Fair Rules Keep Markets Open and Honest names the subject and what the passage argues about it.
  • Free Market Economy is weaker. Names the system, not the passage's case for rules within it.
  • Government Control of Business is weaker. Misstates the stance: the passage defends rules that protect competition and warns against excessive ones (sentence 12).

Mistakes this passage invites

  • Taking a side for or against regulation as such. The passage asks for rules that are proportionate and enforced, and warns against excessive ones (sentence 12).
  • Keeping the three examples of sentence 4 (the polluting factory, the dominant firm, the exposed workers) at full length.
  • Writing that profit is the problem. Sentence 9 says the aim is not to eliminate profit.

Model précis written with AI assistance to this site’s précis rules, then read and approved by Shan Ul Rehman. It is one good answer, not the only one, and not an FPSC answer.

To have your précis marked out of 20, open the Answer Checker, choose Précis & Composition, paste this passage as the Original Passage, then add your précis with its title on the first line.

Check my précis