1A society that values only agreement may appear peaceful, but its calm can conceal fear. 2When people are punished for questioning decisions, mistakes remain uncorrected and resentment moves into private spaces where it is harder to address. 3The right to disagree is not a licence to threaten others or spread deliberate lies. 4It is a safeguard that allows citizens to challenge power through speech, evidence and lawful protest. 5Institutions must protect this right even when criticism is uncomfortable, because the freedom to express popular opinions is rarely the measure of a democracy. 6The real test comes when a minority view is inconvenient. 7Public debate should be judged by the quality of reasons exchanged, not by the volume of applause. 8Citizens, too, must learn to answer arguments without treating every opponent as an enemy. 9Toleration is not passive indifference; it is the discipline of defending another person's freedom while retaining one's own convictions. 10The right to disagree is meaningful only when it is protected in practice. 11A worker who fears dismissal for raising a safety concern, a journalist threatened for investigating public expenditure and a student punished for asking a difficult question all face limits that may not appear in formal law. 12Institutions must protect lawful criticism while providing remedies against threats and harassment. 13Freedom does not remove responsibility: deliberate incitement and direct threats may be subject to lawful restrictions. 14The challenge is to define those limits narrowly and apply them impartially. 15A society gains strength when its members can challenge authority without having to secure personal favour from those they criticise.
Passage 14 of 30
The Right to Disagree
261 words · aim for about 87 (roughly 78–96)
Original practice passage. Written for practice at CSS standard, with AI assistance — it is not a passage from an FPSC past paper. For the real papers, see Précis & Composition past papers.
Task. Write a précis of approximately one-third length and give it a suitable title.
This passage in figures
- Words
- 261
- Sentences
- 15
- Average sentence
- 17 words
- Longest sentence
- 36 words
- Your précis
- 78–96 words, 3–5 sentences
- Sentences per précis sentence
- about 4
It opens: “A society that values only agreement may appear peaceful, but its calm can conceal fear.”
It closes: “A society gains strength when its members can challenge authority without having to secure personal favour from those they criticise.”
How to use these figures, the method step by step, and the mistakes that cost marks: the précis guide.
Model précis
Write your own first, then compare.
Show the model précis for this passage
Central idea
A society that suppresses disagreement only hides fear and leaves its errors uncorrected; the right to disagree, lawful, reasoned and tolerant, and protected in practice with narrow and impartial limits, is what makes a society strong.
Protected Dissent Strengthens a Society
Enforced agreement may look calm but hides fear, leaving mistakes uncorrected and resentment unaddressed. The right excludes threats and lies but allows lawful challenge through speech, evidence and protest. Its test is protecting unpopular views, and a debate is worth its reasons, not its applause. Citizens must answer arguments without making opponents enemies, for toleration defends others' freedom without surrendering one's convictions. The right must work in practice, protecting critics from intimidation, with limits on incitement narrow and impartial. Society grows stronger when authority can be criticised without seeking its favour.
91 words, title not counted, against a target of 87.
Where each sentence comes from
- Enforced agreement may look calm but hides fear, leaving mistakes uncorrected and resentment unaddressed. From passage sentences 1, 2
- The right excludes threats and lies but allows lawful challenge through speech, evidence and protest. From passage sentences 3, 4
- Its test is protecting unpopular views, and a debate is worth its reasons, not its applause. From passage sentences 5, 6, 7
- Citizens must answer arguments without making opponents enemies, for toleration defends others' freedom without surrendering one's convictions. From passage sentences 8, 9
- The right must work in practice, protecting critics from intimidation, with limits on incitement narrow and impartial. From passage sentences 10, 12, 13, 14
- Society grows stronger when authority can be criticised without seeking its favour. From passage sentence 15
Left out: sentence 11 (examples: the worker, the journalist and the student who face unwritten limits).
Why this title
- Protected Dissent Strengthens a Society names the subject and what the passage argues about it.
- Freedom of Speech is weaker. A broad label. The passage is about disagreement with power, its limits, and its protection in practice.
- Unlimited Freedom to Criticise is weaker. Misstates the stance: sentences 3 and 13 exclude threats, lies and incitement.
Mistakes this passage invites
- Treating the right as unlimited. Sentences 3 and 13 set its limits: no threats, no deliberate lies, no incitement.
- Keeping the worker, the journalist and the student of sentence 11 instead of the point they make: the right must hold in practice, not only in law.
- Writing only about the state's duty. Sentence 8 also asks citizens to answer arguments without treating opponents as enemies.
Model précis written with AI assistance to this site’s précis rules, then read and approved by Shan Ul Rehman. It is one good answer, not the only one, and not an FPSC answer.
To have your précis marked out of 20, open the Answer Checker, choose Précis & Composition, paste this passage as the Original Passage, then add your précis with its title on the first line.
Check my précis